Land and Water
Where This Site Stands
Most of this guide reports. Its pages on rock, towns, trails and history say what the record shows and stop there. On four questions about the land and water of the Black Hills, BlackHills.org goes one step further and says what it thinks. This page gives those four positions in short form and points to the pages that carry the facts behind each one.
How the Reporting and the Position Are Kept Apart
The pages on mining, uranium and oil pipelines are built the same way. The facts come first: what exists, what is proposed, who decides, and where things stood on the date given. The case for a mine or a pipeline follows in its backers’ own terms. Then comes the case against, drawn from cleanup records, spill reports, court findings and the positions of tribal governments. The site’s own view comes last, in a marked block headed “Where This Site Stands,” and nowhere else. A reader who disagrees with the block still has the record above it, with every source listed.
Two pages carry no position at all: What the Old Mines Left Behind, which includes the reclamation that worked, and Who Decides, and How to Be Heard. Outside this section the guide stays with reporting, except that its history pages say plainly that the land was stolen.
No New Uranium Mining in or Around the Hills
BlackHills.org opposes new uranium mining in the Black Hills and on the plains around them. “Around” means the counties that touch the Hills, and the Cave Hills of Harding County, where old uranium mines are still being reclaimed. It does not reach Wyoming’s Powder River Basin. The plan now on the table, near Edgemont, would recover uranium through wells drilled into an aquifer, and the Nuclear Regulatory Commission has licensed it; the state’s permits were still pending when this page was last reviewed. Uranium Mining Around the Black Hills has the company’s case, the regulators’ findings, the objections and where each permit stood when the page was last reviewed.
No New or Expanded Mining for Metals or Graphite
BlackHills.org opposes new or expanded mining and exploration drilling for metals and graphite in the Black Hills: gold, uranium, lithium, rare earths and graphite. Limestone, cement and gypsum quarries, gravel pits and bentonite mines are described on this site, not opposed. The Wharf mine near Lead is reported as what it is, a working gold mine; the site opposes expanding it and does not call for closing it.
Mining built many of the towns of the Hills, and the guide tells that history on its pages about the gold rush and the Homestake Mine. Opposing more of it is a judgment about what comes next, not a verdict on the people who did the work. Gold, Lithium and the New Mining Rush covers who is drilling where and under which law.
No Oil Pipelines Across Drinking Water
BlackHills.org opposes oil pipelines across the rivers and aquifers people drink from. Oil Pipelines and the Rivers begins with what does and doesn’t run near the Hills themselves, then follows Keystone XL’s planned route across western South Dakota and Dakota Access to its crossing of the Missouri River. Where the water in question comes from is the subject of Where the Hills’ Water Comes From.
The Land Was Stolen, and the Site Offers No Remedy
The Black Hills were taken from the Lakota and the other tribes of the Great Sioux Reservation in 1877, in violation of the 1868 Fort Laramie Treaty. The treaty made any cession invalid unless at least three-fourths of the adult men signed it. The 1876 agreement was signed by 10 percent of them, the Supreme Court found, after Congress barred further money for the tribes’ food unless they gave up the Hills. On that record the plain word is the accurate one: the land was stolen. The Supreme Court did not use that word. In 1980 it held that the taking had to be paid for, and it ordered no land returned.
What should happen now is a separate question, and the site doesn’t know the answer. It proposes no remedy. Land Back in Plain Terms sets out who asks for what, what a return of land would take and who would have to act; the history is on The 1980 Ruling and Land Back.
What These Positions Are Not
None of the four is a campaign, and these pages ask nothing of the reader. Permits, court cases and bills move, so each one named in this section carries its date, and every page shows the month it was last reviewed. A correction can be sent through the legal notice page.
Connected
- Land Back in Plain TermsThe claim, the refused money and the call for land, kept apart.
- Uranium Mining Around the Black HillsThe Edgemont proposal, its permits and the aquifers.
- Gold, Lithium and the New Mining RushWho is mining and drilling now, and under which law.
- Oil Pipelines and the RiversKeystone XL, Keystone’s spills and Dakota Access at the Missouri.
- Where the Hills’ Water Comes FromThe aquifers and reservoirs these positions are about.
- What the Old Mines Left BehindCleanup costs and reclamation, reported without a position.
- Who Decides, and How to Be HeardWhich agency rules on what.
Sources
- Treaty of Fort Laramie (1868). National Archives, Milestone Documents.
- United States v. Sioux Nation of Indians, 448 U.S. 371. Supreme Court of the United States, 1980 (Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School).
- The sources for each position are listed on the page that carries it.
Last reviewed: